ext_4029 ([identity profile] wojelah.livejournal.com) wrote in [community profile] wintercompanion2012-03-06 10:34 am

Meta Month of March: Ep Discussion: The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances

Captain Jack Harkness. 133 Squadron, Royal Air Force. American volunteer.

And so we meet Jack Harkness. Actually, the first time we meet Jack Harkness, he's complimenting someone's bottom. Multiple someones, come to think of it.

Truthfully, we haven't known Nine all that long at that point, either - we don't have nearly as clear an idea of what exactly happened to him. Mostly, we know there was a war, and they lost. We know he's brusque and funny and closed and damaged, and that he doesn't suffer fools gladly.

Enter Jack, the quintessential trickster. He's a conman. The quintessential Fool, in many respects. He's a pretty face and a great smile, a glib tongue and a lot of Spock. He knows his assets, and he doesn't mind using them. Underneath it all, there's something hard and dangerous - just because you can see teeth doesn't mean it's a grin. And it's hard to laugh when, at bottom, you hate what you've become. I was conning you - that's what I am, I'm a con man.

No lie, I think that's where I first fell for Jack. I wonder if the Doctor doesn't hear it, too. Because while Nine's not impressed - the banana groves at Villengard, anyone? - and he sure as hell doesn't trust Jack - he doesn't write him off, either. More, Jack still manages to slip in under Nine's guard and set him off balance. Consider the sonic screwdriver conversation. Consider further the look on Nine's face when Jack admits to two missing years of memories. And consider the genuine amusement at Jack Harkness, flexible, 51st century flirt.

I'm still not sure where or what, exactly, it is, that lets the Doctor say Do what you've got to do, and trust that Jack's going to do the right thing. I'm not sure either he or Jack are either. I'm not entirely sure I think the Doctor didn't forget about Jack, just briefly, until Rose reminded him. But I think that's part of what I love about these introductory episodes. It's not a meeting of the minds - they're very different, and they're both a little (a LOT) banged up around the edges. Still - there's some sort of recognition, and a dawning sense of respect, amidst the wariness. By the time we move to Boom Town, that dynamic's quite different, and I think that's why I adore post-The Doctor Dances fic as much as I do. There's a bridge to cross at the end of these eps, and I want to know how we get there.

What do you think? Am I giving either of them too much credit? Does Rose act as the bridge between the two? (Me, I am of two minds on this.) What do you think of these eps as Jack's debut? What do you make of the Doctor's reactions? Does Jack earn "companion" status later, after these eps, or do you think the Doctor's made up his mind when he first brings Jack on board?
trobadora: (CK Jack by redscharlach)

[personal profile] trobadora 2012-03-06 04:43 pm (UTC)(link)
I only have a minute - will comment properly later, but before I forget what I wanted to say:

And consider the genuine amusement at Jack Harkness, flexible, 51st century flirt.

That scene where he explains to Rose about humanity and "dancing"? That looks like sheer delight to me. In a way, it's the same thing Jack and Ten talk about later, in Utopia - "End of the universe and here you are. Indomitable!", and "this lot, you see them out here surviving ... and that’s fantastic". What I mean is, Jack is so very vividly alive, and in that he embodies the very thing the Doctor admires about humans. I think that's definitely part of what draws him, con man or no.
trobadora: (Default)

[personal profile] trobadora 2012-03-06 09:41 pm (UTC)(link)
because while Jack flings himself into things, there's a large part he keeps in reserve for those who count. And while the same can be absolutely said of the Doctor, I think they're... different parts?

Yes! I think I know what you mean, anyway. The thing Jack has that the Doctor doesn't is an ability to throw himself into an experience and enjoy it for what it is, deliberately not looking beyond the moment. He can set all the baggage aside for little while, and the Doctor can't. So Jack of course does keep large parts of himself in reserve, but there's something unconditional about his joy, in a way the Doctor can't manage. The Doctor throws himself into things too, but the weight of everything else is always present at the back of his mind, even if he chooses not to pay attention to it. Is that what you were getting at?

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2012-03-06 22:14 (UTC) - Expand

[identity profile] iolo1234.livejournal.com 2012-03-06 06:03 pm (UTC)(link)
I fell in love with Jack from the moment he said 'excellent bottom'. I wasn't a particularly big JB fan then but being a lover of musicals and LIve and Kicking I knew of him. Even though JB prefers being with DT I think he's better with CE. I loved the flirting in Boom Town - such an under-rated episode in my opinion.
In this he starts as a conman but is redeemed by the Doctor. I wonder did anyone notice the parallel conversation of Jack to the Doctor - I was a coward - wish I hadn't met you etc in Parting of the Ways to Rex saying almost exactly the same to Jack about wishing he'd never met him in the last ep of MD.
One of my favourite bits is when the Doctor explains to Rose about 51st century dancing and also the chat with the computer when he thinks he's going to die - so out there to talk about sleeping with both your executioners in DW.
For me Jack was such a break through character for DW and he set the tone for more gay characters and references. Long live RTD and SM and the gay agenda and long live Jack Harkness and his swishy coat.
trobadora: (Jack kissing by kataclysmic)

[personal profile] trobadora 2012-03-06 10:11 pm (UTC)(link)
Hee! Like [livejournal.com profile] wojelah, I'd never so much as heard of JB before Jack, but I completely fell in love with him here. ♥ ♥ ♥

And I really can't imagine Doctor Who without Jack - you're right, for all that he's been in so few episodes, he's been incredibly important in setting the tone.

I wonder did anyone notice the parallel conversation of Jack to the Doctor

Yes! It's not the first time, of course, that Jack has been to other people what the Doctor was to him, but that was lovely, to have it made so explicit.

(And Boom Town is one of my favourite episodes! Can't wait to hear your comments when we get to that ep!)

[identity profile] 10littlebullets.livejournal.com 2012-03-07 07:31 pm (UTC)(link)
the parallel conversation of Jack to the Doctor - I was a coward - wish I hadn't met you etc in Parting of the Ways

Not to anticipate later episodes too much (*g*), but this actually made me think of the Doctor's climactic decision in Parting of the Ways and the lines "Coward or killer?" "Coward. Every time." And I just realized that, in a way, he and Jack follow inverse character arcs in s1: Jack started out working for the Time Agency, was presumably forced to sacrifice way too much in the line of duty, and struck out on his own. What we see over the course of TEC/TDD is a man who insists on being accountable only to himself realizing--slowly and uncomfortably, though with Jack's usual charming good cheer--that he's found something more important than his own self-interest, and casting his lot in with a team. In TDD he demonstrates it with a grand self-sacrificing gesture that saves everyone's butts; by Parting of the Ways he's willing to lay down his life like a soldier just to buy the Doctor more time.

Whereas the Doctor spent centuries on end (the entire classic series, pretty much) as an itinerant spacetime adventurer merrily thumbing his nose at duty, and then the Time War happened. We don't know exactly what happened or how the Time Lords got him to come back home and do his part for the fatherland, all we know is that Nine spends most of s1 acting like a soldier having one hell of a time readjusting to civilian life and getting his solo-adventurer (well, dynamic-duo adventurer) groove back. Jack's big triumph of character development is being able to lay down cowardice and selfishness in service of a higher cause; Nine, coming from the opposite direction, also triumphs when he refuses to kill civilians in cold blood for a higher cause, even if it means cowardice and selfishness and being just one individual who can't bring himself to cross the wires no matter what his inaction might mean.

(At some point I really need to go back and assemble a timeline of reveals about the Time War; right now I'm not even sure whether the parallels with the destruction of Gallifrey were meant to be obvious at the time or only in hindsight.)

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2012-03-08 08:49 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2012-03-09 08:19 (UTC) - Expand
trobadora: (Default)

[personal profile] trobadora 2012-03-08 08:47 am (UTC)(link)
And I just realized that, in a way, he and Jack follow inverse character arcs in s1

Oh, that's a fascinating take on it! You're right, that makes so much sense.

And I'd love to see your timeline - it's so easy to forget what we knew when, and I'm afraid I've long lost track of it.
trobadora: (CK Jack by redscharlach)

[personal profile] trobadora 2012-03-06 10:07 pm (UTC)(link)
Okay, a proper comment now!

No lie, I think that's where I first fell for Jack.

I wish I could remember when I fell for Jack, but I marathoned the season, and my first watch all sort of blurs together. This is a great moment, though - you're absolutely right about the self-loathing under the surface, and that's when you know there really is more to him.

I don't know if you remember the discussion from way back when about how Jack is constructed in these episodes - I think it was legionseagle who pointed out that while many American viewers took him for a stereotypical pretty soldier hero, for the British (or European) eye he was rather the opposite. The first impression we got of him was "smarmy American" and "fake", someone not to be trusted - and the surprise twist was that he's actually a good guy underneath. Okay, it's not nearly as blatant as that, but those undercurrents are definitely there. And either way, he's so much more than he initially seems.

Because while Nine's not impressed - the banana groves at Villengard, anyone? - and he sure as hell doesn't trust Jack - he doesn't write him off, either. More, Jack still manages to slip in under Nine's guard and set him off balance.

I think the Doctor found himself liking Jack despite himself - he thought he shouldn't, but he did.

I'm still not sure where or what, exactly, it is, that lets the Doctor say Do what you've got to do, and trust that Jack's going to do the right thing.

He's clearly got Jack's measure by that point, though when exactly he reached that point I don't know either. It's a gradual process, probably - all the small revelations over the course of the ep adding up to this.

I'm not entirely sure I think the Doctor didn't forget about Jack, just briefly, until Rose reminded him.

This is the part I can never decide about. Watching the scene, it does look like he completely forgot Jack just sacrificed himself - and doesn't care, out of sight, out of mind. Only that doesn't quite gel with the Doctor's characterisation either, and at any rate it wouldn't have truly been "everybody lives" if someone had died, no matter who. So it remains a strange, uncomfortable, ambiguous moment that I never know what to do with. If anyone has a theory, I'd love to hear it!

Still - there's some sort of recognition, and a dawning sense of respect, amidst the wariness. By the time we move to Boom Town, that dynamic's quite different, and I think that's why I adore post-The Doctor Dances fic as much as I do. There's a bridge to cross at the end of these eps, and I want to know how we get there.

Yes! I won't go into Boom Town now - that's for the next discussion - but that missing period between episodes is so fascinating. You could argue equally well that they're already nearly there, or that they still have a lot of territory to cross, but either way, there's a threshold crossed somewhere in between, and I can never get enough of that.

(continued in next comment)
Edited 2012-03-06 22:07 (UTC)
trobadora: (CK Jack by redscharlach)

[personal profile] trobadora 2012-03-06 10:08 pm (UTC)(link)
Does Rose act as the bridge between the two? (Me, I am of two minds on this.)

I really don't think she does. Jack connects with Rose differently than he does with the Doctor, or than she does with the Doctor, and their issues are different - and on top of that, the Doctor's clearly more than a little jealous at that point. (You can take that in a shippy sense or not - at any rate, he wants Rose's attention, and Jack is immensely entertaining, so definitely competition on that front. *g*) So I'm not sure how well she could be the bridge between them - rather, I think for the three of them to achieve a comfortable balance, Jack and the Doctor have to connect in a way that's separate and independent of Rose. (Er. I'm not sure I'm explaining this well. Did that make any sense outside my head?)

Does Jack earn "companion" status later, after these eps, or do you think the Doctor's made up his mind when he first brings Jack on board?

That's a really good question! I think about 99% of the fic I've read assumes that Jack still has to earn his companion status, but somehow I always had the impression the Doctor had already made up his mind. They still had a long way to go, but I think the Doctor knew by that point that he could trust Jack where it mattered, and also, he just plain liked having him around.

--

And here I've gone two long comments without even saying anything about Jack's sexuality, or how much I love its portrayal in this ep, and the Doctor's joyful, delighted description of humanity "dancing" among the stars in the future! Well, that can't be right, so let me just add that I still, after all these years, wish the Doctor had danced with Jack there at the end. (Danced, people! Danced, not "danced". Although that too, of course. *g*)

(no subject)

[identity profile] wendymr.livejournal.com - 2012-03-07 00:27 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[identity profile] wendymr.livejournal.com - 2012-03-07 02:22 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[identity profile] wendymr.livejournal.com - 2012-03-07 04:04 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2012-03-07 08:55 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2012-03-07 08:55 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2012-03-07 08:45 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2012-03-07 08:39 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2012-03-07 08:36 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2012-03-07 08:42 (UTC) - Expand

[identity profile] magic-7-words.livejournal.com 2012-03-07 12:16 am (UTC)(link)
I think what made me first fall for Jack was the scene in which he rescued Rose from the barrage balloon. As Rose says, "that's up there with flossing." So he's the dashing hero coming to the rescue, which is great, and he has a sense of humor, which is great. And then Rose faints in his arms, which made me a little nervous when I saw it, because all we know about Jack at this point is that a) he finds Rose sexually attractive, and b) he's not who he pretends to be. And remember, the last time Rose fainted in a stranger's arms (the undertaker in "The Unquiet Dead") she later accused him of feeling her up. But Jack's a perfect gentleman even when nobody's watching, which basically characterized him in my mind as someone who would come through when it really counted.

I know there's precedent for Nine forgetting people (like Mickey in the first episode), but I have difficulty believing the Doctor could forget about Jack so thoroughly that he could proclaim "Everybody lives!" without running a quick mental tally and coming up one short. My theory is that when he tells Jack "Get rid of the bomb as safely as you can," he genuinely doesn't put it together that he's sending Jack to his death. Danger, yes. Certain death, no. So it's only when Rose asks "Why did he say goodbye?" that the Doctor realizes his rescue services are required.

As for the companion status question, I'm going to hedge and say that yes, the Doctor invited him on board and that qualifies him as a companion, but obviously there's a long way to go between that and the finishing-each-other's-sentences dynamic we see in "Boom Town."
trobadora: (Default)

[personal profile] trobadora 2012-03-07 08:31 am (UTC)(link)
But Jack's a perfect gentleman even when nobody's watching, which basically characterized him in my mind as someone who would come through when it really counted.

I'm reluctant to give him too much credit just for not taking advantage, but it's definitely a point in Jack's favour. Along with rescuing Rose in the first place, and then going along with her and the Doctor while they try to figure out and cure the gas mask people. Jack's a con man, and he doesn't believe at that point that he has anything to do with it, but still he doesn't turn away. I think that matters, too.

I have difficulty believing the Doctor could forget about Jack so thoroughly that he could proclaim "Everybody lives!" without running a quick mental tally and coming up one short. My theory is that when he tells Jack "Get rid of the bomb as safely as you can," he genuinely doesn't put it together that he's sending Jack to his death.

I like that theory! It's just that look the Doctor gives him when Jack goes off to do his thing - I can't see that and not believe the Doctor knows exactly what Jack is going to do, and what it'll cost him. Honestly, I don't know how to reconcile it all. I wish I did!

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2012-03-07 18:20 (UTC) - Expand

[identity profile] wendymr.livejournal.com 2012-03-07 02:36 am (UTC)(link)
Returning to an aspect of the Nine and Jack dynamic I mentioned in my reply t [livejournal.com profile] trobadora above: while I won't anticipate later episodes, in which Jack clearly knows what the Doctor is, what do we think Jack thought of the Doctor in these two episodes? We've had a lot of discussion about what the Doctor thought of Jack, but all Jack knows about the Doctor is:

1: he thinks he's a Time Agent
2: he then thinks he's a 'freelance', whatever that means
3: he makes fun of the Doctor's inadequate sonic device, but then he's also seen the Doctor pick up psychic signals and insult their 'tiny human brains', and he's heard Rose comment that the Doctor insults other species while shaving (can't remember the specific line)
4: the Doctor clearly knows a lot about temporal theory and time-ships, given his scathing comments about how long it took Jack to adjust the settings on his ship so that he could rescue the two of them, and that he recognises it as a Chula ship and knows about the nanogenes
5: and then, of course, at the end of the episode he sees inside the TARDIS and realises that it's bigger on the inside.

So, at the end of the episode, what do we think Jack is thinking about the Doctor? And - other than having felt embarrassed/humbled over his mistake with the ambulance, and grateful for having his life saved - does he at this point even like the Doctor?

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2012-03-07 09:04 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2012-03-07 18:21 (UTC) - Expand
trobadora: (Default)

[personal profile] trobadora 2012-03-07 09:03 am (UTC)(link)
Oooh! Those are excellent questions!

what do we think Jack is thinking about the Doctor?

I can really go either way with this - Jack already having figured out what the Doctor is, or Jack being totally flummoxed when he finds out later. We never do see Jack find out anything; at some point he just knows. About the Time Lords; about the Time War; about Gallifrey, lateron - and it works well that he knows when he does, but I still wish we could at least sometimes have seen him find out!

does he at this point even like the Doctor?

Oh, absolutely. I think it's quite easy to get to "like" with Jack - it's anything deeper that takes time. Now, if there's anything deeper there already? I'm not really decided on this, though it might be. There is, after all, that moment when Jack goes off to sacrifice himself, and the look they share when the Doctor sends him off - it always seemed to me like a look of perfect understanding, and the moment when something more serious started. Does that make any sense?

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2012-03-07 18:22 (UTC) - Expand

[identity profile] magic-7-words.livejournal.com 2012-03-07 12:23 pm (UTC)(link)
I think part of Jack must really like watching the Doctor in action, so to speak. The mad schemes, manic grin, boundless energy and enthusiasm, the chutzpah to go up against the world armed with only his wits and a sonic screwdriver. It's all I can figure given his actions later on, when he's falling over himself just to hang out with the Doctor again despite the Doctor trying to ignore his existence. And it's not so far-fetched that Jack would enjoy being with the Doctor for the same reasons we enjoy watching him on the screen. And if that's the case, I don't see why it wouldn't have started by now. Obviously he's not madly in love (yet), but I can see him thinking something like "you gotta admit, that man's got style."

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2012-03-07 18:18 (UTC) - Expand
yamx: (Default)

[personal profile] yamx 2012-03-07 06:06 am (UTC)(link)
One of my favorite moments in those eps is when the Doctor figures out what's been going on with the nanogenes and explains it, and Jack finally realizes that this whole thing is indeed his fault. That look on his face, and his voice... Up to then, he seemed unwilling to take responsibility for his screw-up, but that's the moment you can see he *does* feel responsible--he just really hadn't thought his actions could have caused this. (Which makes his willingness to help Rose and the Doctor get into the bombsite even more remarkable.)

Also awesome and, of course, hilarious, is the infamous screwdriver/blaster one-upmanship conversation. "Well, I've got a banana, and in a pinch you could put up some shelves. Wow, the assets conversation went in a flash, didn't it?" *giggles*
trobadora: (Default)

[personal profile] trobadora 2012-03-07 08:57 am (UTC)(link)
Up to then, he seemed unwilling to take responsibility for his screw-up, but that's the moment you can see he *does* feel responsible--he just really hadn't thought his actions could have caused this.

Yes! That's such a great moment.

Well, I've got a banana, and in a pinch you could put up some shelves. Wow, the assets conversation went in a flash, didn't it?"

One of my favourite lines from the ep! :D :D :D

(Also, as an aside, while lateron the sonic screwdriver became more and more the magic wand that could do practically ANYTHING, I love that it really isn't here.)

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2012-03-07 18:20 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2012-03-07 23:02 (UTC) - Expand

[identity profile] scifiangel.livejournal.com 2012-03-08 03:13 pm (UTC)(link)
There have been so many wonderful observations so far, even though I haven't had the time to read all of them. I wanted to get my thoughts down before they became too influenced.

I fell in love with Jack almost immediately, even before I was in love with the Doctor (Nine). I had watched Doctor Who back in the late 70's and early 80's with the Fourth Doctor. Being an American we didn't get the episodes on a regular basis. I liked the show, but I was never in love with it. When Jack stepped onto the scene I fell in love with not only him, but the show as well.

My first impression of Jack was how much he reminded me of Han Solo from Star Wars. The handsome and charming rogue with the heart of gold. I so loved his conversation with Nine about "sonic" blaster vs. "sonic" screwdriver. "Who looks at a screwdriver and think ooowe this could be more sonic?" And then later when Nine wants a list of assets, "Well I have a banana and in a pinch you can put up some shelves." He made me laugh and it showed that he can hold his own against the Doctor.

The conversation about his memories being stolen grabbed my heart. I though how much alike he was to the Doctor (solders that had been hurt.) When Jack said that the Doctor may have good reason not to trust him, I could tell Jack was almost afraid to find out what his memories were. Afraid he had done something terrible. Near the end of The Doctor Dances when Jack realizes that it is all his fault, you can see the anguish in his face. He turns around and puts his head in his hand. I was completely in love with him at that moment. I just wanted to run over and hug him.

His death conversation with his computer was so poignant. It's said you never truly know someone until you see how they handle death. How he handled it made me love him even more. Jack is definitely "Bigger on the Inside."


[identity profile] magic-7-words.livejournal.com 2012-03-09 01:40 am (UTC)(link)
Ooh, yes, I made the Han Solo connection too.
trobadora: (Default)

[personal profile] trobadora 2012-03-09 08:29 am (UTC)(link)
My first impression of Jack was how much he reminded me of Han Solo from Star Wars.

Yeah, that's what I meant above - I think he came across as that archetype far more to the American audience, whereas the European reaction was a bit different -Jack's initial presentation deliberately plays into certain of our stereotypes about Americans.

Oh yes, he's definitely bigger on the inside!

(no subject)

[identity profile] scifiangel.livejournal.com - 2012-03-09 19:35 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2012-03-10 17:46 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[identity profile] scifiangel.livejournal.com - 2012-03-10 20:01 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2012-03-10 20:16 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[identity profile] scifiangel.livejournal.com - 2012-03-10 20:25 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[identity profile] scifiangel.livejournal.com - 2012-03-09 19:41 (UTC) - Expand